I've had experience with three of them: (1) A '99 Passat who's trans broke around 120K miles (something came apart in the torque converter, punched a hole, dumping the OEM fluid in a huge puddle), (2) a '96 A4 that was still shifting like new at over 270K miles when sold, using MaxLife ATF, and (3) an '05 A4 3.0 with almost 180K miles, no issues, MaxLife ATF. The '99 now has a used, replacement transaxle, and around 150K on it.