might have to disagree a little with you ....
This would be a test of driver vs. driver ....
The charger stock runs 1/4 mile in 13.5, the wrx sti 13.4 ... with the extra 55hp and torque in the charger over stock and a equal driver I am pretty sure the charger would beat the STI. Now I have had only 1 STI driver try to pass me, key word was TRY. I owned a WRX (non-sti) and they are amazingly fast off the line, but if the driver can't get that thing into second gear quick enough it is all over for them. Funny How off the line it comes down to traction and driver more than anything when the cars are so close in specs.
I love my B6 and didn't buy it for a performance car, but after I drove it and had it chipped ... I said WOW this thing is pretty fun to drive. I am not gonna race every body that comes along, but it is good to know that when I step on the gas it goes without hesitation.