Wow, 94R for $140 from Pep Boys?!
Do yourself a favor and just go for a Grp. 48/91 Interstate MTP-91. I replaced my 4 y/o MTP-91 for a new one last Fri for $89+ out the door, and that includes the installation from Interstate Batteries of LA (a mere 2 blocks from home)...roughly the same price I paid for mine exactly 4yrs ago in 12/04 ($85) from a batt dealer. Following the warranty, the Interstate dude priced the new one based on months used for the old (48mos x 1.72 = $82.56 + tax).
MTP-91 [examples: 1995 BMW 318i and 1990 BMW 325i and 1991 BMW 318i and 2001 Z3 (all)] Pro-rata warranty: 85 months
Weight: 38.80 pounds
Length: 11.38 inches
Width: 6.88 inches
Height: 6.88 inches
Cranking Amps: 875
Cold Cranking Amps: 700
Voltage: 12
No problems at all for fitting...the oem bracket fits perfectly, and it even has the breathing tube, just like the oem German Moll battery it originally replaced when I bought the B5 new. Oh btw, this new batt now comes with 30 months free replacement (previous unit had 18 mos free).